COLUMBIA, S.C. — A legal dispute surrounding the line-of-duty death of Irmo firefighter James Michael “J” Muller has escalated, with the Irmo Fire District seeking the immediate termination of two senior Columbia fire officials as part of a proposed settlement.
The district is calling for the removal of Columbia-Richland Fire Chief Aubrey Jenkins and Assistant Chief of Operations Anthony Holloway, according to a recent court filing.
The demands are part of an offer of judgment filed in Richland County Common Pleas Court this week, as litigation continues over Muller’s death during a May 26, 2023, apartment building fire. Firehouse+1
Settlement Demands Include Terminations and Public Apologies
Under the proposed terms, the Irmo Fire District is seeking:
- Immediate termination of Chief Aubrey Jenkins and Assistant Chief Anthony Holloway.
- Reimbursement of approximately $40,000 in legal expenses.
- A written public apology from Jenkins concerning allegations that Irmo firefighters provided false statements to investigators.
- A written public apology from Holloway concerning allegations that Irmo Assistant Chief Sloane Valentino improperly influenced a federal investigation into Muller’s death.
The demands are settlement conditions proposed by Irmo, not orders issued by a judge. Neither official has been removed as a result of the filing.
Columbia has 20 days to respond to the offer. If the parties cannot reach an agreement, litigation could continue, with potential consequences involving legal costs. Firehouse+1
Firefighter Killed During 2023 Apartment Fire
Muller, 25, died on May 26, 2023, while assisting with firefighting operations at the Tropical Ridge Apartments in Columbia, South Carolina.
He was killed when part of the burning structure collapsed during the emergency response.
His widow, Emma Muller, subsequently filed a wrongful death lawsuit alleging that decisions made during firefighting operations contributed to the fatal collapse and complicated efforts to rescue him.
The lawsuit raises concerns about fireground communication, incident command, personnel accountability and the use of high-volume water streams on the damaged structure.
Irmo was not originally named as a defendant in the widow’s lawsuit. However, the City of Columbia later brought the district into the litigation through a third-party claim, arguing that Irmo should share potential financial responsibility. https://www.wistv.com+2
Federal Investigation Identified Fireground Safety Failures
A 2025 investigation by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) identified several contributing factors in Muller’s death.
Among the issues examined were communication failures, inadequate personnel accountability and insufficient understanding of the building’s structural condition.
The findings highlighted the importance of coordinated incident command, structural risk assessments and effective firefighter emergency procedures.
The investigation was intended to identify circumstances contributing to the fatality and recommend measures to prevent similar incidents. It did not determine civil liability in the ongoing lawsuit. The State+1
Additional Allegations Involving Mutual Aid
The legal dispute has also raised questions about the relationship between the Columbia-Richland Fire Department and the Irmo Fire District.
Court filings submitted by Muller’s legal team allege that Columbia threatened to withhold mutual aid assistance from Irmo during disagreements over financial responsibility in the lawsuit.
The City of Columbia has disputed those allegations.
The controversy has drawn attention to the importance of mutual aid agreements, which allow neighboring fire departments to provide personnel, equipment and emergency resources when additional assistance is needed. https://www.wistv.com+1
Separate Defamation Lawsuit Involving Fire Chief
Jenkins is also involved in separate litigation against the Professional Firefighters Association of South Carolina and its president, Roger Odachowski.
In that lawsuit, Jenkins alleges the association made defamatory statements blaming his leadership for operational shortcomings associated with Muller’s death.
The association has disputed the allegations.
The separate legal action adds another dimension to the controversy surrounding the department’s leadership and its response to the 2023 tragedy. The State
Legal Proceedings Continue
As of November 19, the proposed settlement has not been publicly confirmed as accepted.
The wrongful death litigation continues, with depositions and other pretrial proceedings examining the decisions and actions taken during the fatal fire.
The case could proceed to trial in 2027 if the parties do not reach a resolution.
For the fire service, the litigation also raises broader questions concerning firefighter accountability, incident command, emergency communications and responsibility when multiple agencies respond to the same incident.
First Source News will continue following developments in the case.
